Fracking causes earthquakes.
This claim is largely inaccurate, though it may contain a kernel of truth.
Full Analysis
Detailed examination of the evidence
Context#
Anti-fracking activists frequently claim that hydraulic fracturing causes dangerous earthquakes. This conflates fracking with an entirely different process: wastewater disposal.
Evidence#
What Fracking Actually Does
- Hydraulic fracturing creates micro-seismic events typically below magnitude 1
- These are imperceptible to humans and pose zero risk
- The process occurs thousands of feet underground in targeted rock formations
- Millions of fracking operations have been conducted safely
The Real Cause of Induced Seismicity
- Wastewater injection wells—not fracking—are linked to larger earthquakes
- This is a separate process that disposes of produced water
- Only a small fraction of injection wells have caused issues
- The industry has implemented protocols that have dramatically reduced events
Oklahoma: The Misleading Example
- Seismicity was linked to wastewater disposal wells, not fracking
- When disposal practices changed, earthquake rates dropped 90%+
- This demonstrates the industry's ability to solve the problem
- Conflating disposal wells with fracking is scientifically inaccurate
Industry Success Story
- Oklahoma's induced seismicity peaked in 2015
- Improved regulations and industry practices resolved the issue
- Seismic monitoring and "traffic light" systems now standard
- Proves responsible development is achievable
Analysis#
This claim is mostly false because it fundamentally confuses two different processes. Hydraulic fracturing itself causes only micro-seismic events that are too small to feel. The larger earthquakes that made headlines were caused by wastewater disposal wells—a separate operation.
More importantly, this is a solved problem. The industry worked with regulators to develop monitoring systems and operational changes that have reduced induced seismicity by over 90% in affected areas. This is a success story of industry-government cooperation, not an indictment of fracking.
Calling fracking dangerous based on wastewater injection is like blaming automobiles for oil refinery emissions—technically related but fundamentally misleading.